• 20230909-155017-braden
  • 20230919-201152-Banks-McLaughlin2C20Keefe20Jensen2C20Benavente2C20Braden.png
  • 20230919-201229-Bill20Kirby20col20sig

Juveniles committing crimes is nothing new to this community.

We were discussing the same subject in 2014.

“We have to take time to provide for young people,” Sheriff  Earl “Moose” Butler was saying at a Safe Streets Symposium that drew folks to the Crown Expo Center, where the late Cumberland County sheriff reminded us about Y.W. Howard, the late teacher and coach at Massey Hill High School, and where Howard always saw that kids from “the hill” had plenty of activities to keep them out of trouble.

Harold Medlock, the former police chief, was there.

“We have a serious problem with youth violence, kids with no direction,” Medlock said. “They don’t have parental direction.”

Apparently, if you listen to Kemberle Braden, today’s city police chief, juvenile crime still is a problem, and perhaps it is worse now than almost a decade ago. And it is why the Fayetteville City Council finds itself debating a youth curfew proposed by Braden that opponents say just won’t solve the issue.

Braden, 49, agrees that a curfew may not be the end-all solution, rather a tool for police to at least stem juvenile crime in the city.

The proposed Youth Protection Ordinance, aka the curfew, would not allow young people under the age of 18 from being out in public in the city from 1 to 5 a.m. Monday through Friday and from midnight to 5 a.m. on weekends. For young people under age 16, the hours of the proposed curfew are 11 p.m. to 6 a.m. on weekdays and weekends.

Pros and cons of both sides

There are two sides to the curfew argument.

“Although I support a curfew, I think that you should be in at a decent time,” Councilwoman Courtney Banks-McLaughlin said Monday at a specially called City Council meeting to take a closer look at the proposed curfew. “My husband has a curfew, but on a serious note, my concerns are the placement for the youth. I know I mentioned in a previous meeting I would rather see kids sitting in a hallway at DSS rather than parents having to bury their children or kids, you know, in harm’s way. However, I think that there needs to be a (memorandum of understanding) or resolution from the agencies even down to the school system” and “Department of Social Services, where we can collaborate, because I feel like we don’t have the answers.”

Councilwoman Kathy Keefe Jensen said she understands both sides of the curfew, too.

But …

“I do not believe that anybody under 18 needs to be outside at 1 o’clock or after 12,” Jensen said. “And nobody’s going to change my mind on that.”

For police to have authority to stop young people from 7 a.m. to 4 p.m. during school hours is a concern, and the councilwoman will not support that part of the curfew proposal.

Mario Benavente, a freshman councilman, isn’t buying into the curfew as proposed, and Benavente on Monday let Braden know in no uncertain terms to the point of all but being about as rude as a councilman may ever have been over the past 30 years. Benavente accused the police chief of cherry-picking juvenile crime statistics to curry favor for the curfew proposal and, at one point, told Braden, “It’s very difficult to trust that you’re not just trying to fight for a very particular outcome,” and later saying, “You’re just dead set on having a reason to stop and frisk people in this city.”

In the words, councilman, of that old Beach Boys song, “Help me, Rhonda.”

That’s preposterous.

Benavente also reminded the chief about the American Civil Liberties Union that has told the council a curfew infringes on the rights of young people. Excuse me, councilman, let me tell you about my constitutional rights when growing up as a teenager under the age of 18 in this city. My constitutional rights ended with my father and my mother, and there was no negotiating my civil rights when I was coming up.

Still, the councilman is passionate about his position.

“Everyone agrees that young people should be somewhere safe after hours,” Benavente said.  “I think that’s the one piece of common ground that we all have. … It doesn’t have to be a curfew. It can be one of a dozen different ideas. Let’s start from the real Square 1. Get all the partners together to discuss youth crime and how we can impact it. Let’s start from Step 1. We don’t need to come in there with curfews and the baggage of an ordinance. You don’t have to put lipstick on a pig with this. We can just talk about the common ground that we all have. Young  people need to be protected and need to be safe. Are the police the best tool for that? There’s a lot of data out there that says they’re actually the worst tool.”

A preacher’s words

But back to that 2014 Safe Streets Symposium, if you will, when Police Chief Harold Medlock was saying there was a “serious problem with youth violence” and “kids with no direction” from their parents.

Denise Taylor of Sampson County weighed in on youth violence, telling the story she recalls hearing from her pastor in Harnett County. The good reverend’s story had to do with young people and drugs. Parents, as Taylor related the preacher’s words,  “drug” their kids to church on Sunday mornings, and they “drug” them by the ears when talking back or misbehaving, and, if necessary, “drug” them to the woodshed.

Taylor said she could remember just what her minister said: “Those drugs are still in my veins,  and they affect my behavior in everything I do, say and think. … And, if today’s children had this kind of drug problem, the world would be a better place.”

And back to Monday night, when the City Council voted to look not only deeper into a youth curfew, but one that will need partnership with other stakeholders to include the Cumberland County Department of Social Services, input from Cumberland County Sheriff Ennis Wright, the Cumberland County District Attorney’s Office, the Cumberland County Public Defender’s Office, local judges and any agency or organization that can find a way to mitigate juvenile crime.

“We need everybody at the table: the county, the school board, the judges,” Councilwoman Banks-McLaughlin said Monday night, and the councilwoman said it right.

No matter how all of this plays out, for now, juvenile crime is an issue, according to the police chief, and the police chief says he has seen juvenile crime up close in this city, and it is a reason for concern — a reason for all of us to be concerned.

Epilogue

Most of you don’t know or remember the late Clyde Parrish, the old teacher and successful football coach at Red Springs High School in the 1980s.

But I do, and I remember his prophetic words in 1987 about the school’s concerns about students at the Robeson County high school.

“We decided one night to go through the neighborhoods and see if the parents knew where their kids were,” Parrish said. “We knocked, and all the kids came to the doors … and they didn’t know where their parents were.”

Something, if I may, to give thought to in this juvenile crime equation.

Bill Kirby Jr. can be reached  at billkirby49@gmail.com or 910-624-1961.

The CityView News Fund is a nonprofit organization that supports CityView’s newsgathering operation. Will you help us with a tax-deductible donation? 

Bill Kirby Jr. is a veteran journalist who spent 49 years as a newspaper editor, reporter and columnist covering Fayetteville, Cumberland County and the Cape Fear Region for The Fayetteville Observer. He most recently has written for CityView Magazine.