In the past 14 months, two members of a volunteer board that is supposed to advise the Fayetteville Police Department have resigned from their roles. Both stepped down just months into their terms, citing concern over the trajectory of what they say is a board that’s advisory in name only, but in reality, is a cheering squad for the police department.

Jeremy Fiebig resigned from the Community Police Advisory Board last September because it had become an “advocacy body that works on behalf of FPD rather than an advisory body,” he wrote in his Sept. 18 resignation letter to city council. Though he had only served on the board for five months, Fiebig was the second member to resign in less than a year. 

Citing nearly identical reasons to Fiebig, William Grace resigned in January 2024, after being appointed to the board in April 2023. Members are appointed for three-year terms. 

Both Grace and Fiebig are white men, and are active in the Fayetteville community with extensive volunteer experience. Fiebig is a professor at Fayetteville State University. Grace has worked at and supported the preservation of Fayetteville bookstore BJ’s Used Books for many years. In interviews, neither Fiebig nor Grace expressed the belief that police forces should be abolished, defunded or disarmed. 

“I am pro-police when they follow the laws and protect all citizens of our community,” Grace told CityView. “Many police officers do just that on a daily basis. However, I am anti-police when those officers who abuse their authority, treat citizens with disrespect or otherwise harm citizens, whether knowingly or by mistake, and are not held accountable when they do wrong.”

Yet Grace and Fiebig’s departure has sparked a debate over what police oversight and accountability mean in Fayetteville as the country continues to grapple with complex and deeply rooted questions about systemic racism and police brutality in the wake of George Floyd’s death and the Black Lives Matter protests that followed.

Overview of board, criticisms

In June 2020, the Fayetteville City Council responded to Floyd’s death and protests against police brutality by passing a resolution to create a “citizen review board.” The board would “provide greater oversight, review, and accountability on all aspects of policing, but most specifically on any issues regarding the use of force, brutality, and misconduct by members of the Fayetteville Police Department,” meeting minutes state. 

The council ultimately modified the original proposition, moving from oversight to advising when it established the Community Police Advisory Board (CPAB) in August 2021. CPAB is an all-volunteer board.

CPAB is tasked with making recommendations to the city council for policy improvements to the police department and improving discourse between FPD and the public. Yet the board has so far failed to produce a policy recommendation for the city council — despite it being a tenet of CPAB’s mission statement — and the Fayetteville City Council has not required more from the board than a yearly report. 

William Grace

Both Fiebig and Grace have accused the board’s chair, police chaplain Greg Perkins, of deliberately stifling critique of the FPD at board meetings. Perkins is a volunteer chaplain with the police department and has been involved in the department’s community outreach programs. He also previously worked in law enforcement as a juvenile probation officer, according to his application to CPAB.

Fiebig and Grace described the board as ineffective and biased towards the police department. At meetings, members are discouraged from voicing criticism, Fiebig and Grace claimed, while potential recommendations for improvement are quickly shot down. Dissent, of any kind, is at least frowned upon — and at most, blatantly discouraged. 

The disarray found within Fayetteville’s police advisory board comes after the city’s Ethics Commission was accused of inaction and lacking transparency following the repeated dismissal of recent complaints, including about the mayor and former police chief. It also comes as other police advisory boards across the state have faced troubles, with Chapel Hill disbanding its board last November and Charlotte’s board refusing to hold public meetings. 

Fayetteville’s CPAB, according to its charter, is supposed to “educate and advocate with the public” through town halls and community events “on wide ranging police, safety, and justice, and responses to critical incidents.” 

Fiebig and Grace contend the board’s current membership, which currently includes a retired police detective, a retired parole officer and a police chaplain, is at the root of the issue.

“It became fairly clear fairly quickly,” Fiebig told CityView, “that it was more like an advocacy board — like that was what the ‘ask’ was of the group.”

The National Civic League’s Center for Democracy Innovation, a nonprofit organization focused on advancing civic engagement, examined two Fayetteville boards — CPAB and the Fayetteville Next Advisory Commission — as part of its independent efforts to boost public engagement in local government meetings. The study, which analyzed CPAB in the first half of 2024, found that CPAB meetings had “very low attendance,” and attributed this in part to the divisions among the board about its purpose.

“It seems likely that CPAB members are limiting the appeal of attendance by reminding the community of its advisory nature,” the study states. “CPAB has a very clear charter, but there is some division and confusion about what role the board should serve. Other interviewees pointed out that CPAB is not committing to having public input directly inform how the board presents ideas for discussion at council meetings.” 

There are currently 23 civilian police advisory boards in North Carolina, according to the UNC School of Government. A 2020 report from the North Carolina Task Force for Racial Equity in Criminal Justice, established by former Gov. Roy Cooper, recommended the state expand the investigative and oversight authority of these boards.

“At present, North Carolina has few civilian oversight boards, and those that exist have very little meaningful authority,” the report states. “This hampers the extent to which these boards can serve as true instruments of accountability. Further, the lack of data law enforcement agencies collect limits efforts to ensure that our agencies are functioning as they should to protect and serve all North Carolinians equally.”

Along with other North Carolina municipalities’ citizens review boards, the City of Raleigh’s board faced criticism in 2020, with advocates and members describing it as a “facade of police accountability.” 

‘Community canvassing’

A central point of contention within CPAB revolved around a “community canvassing” initiative proposed by Perkins at the October meeting. This initiative, which board members described as gathering feedback from the public and in some cases correcting perceived misinformation about the police department, sparked a debate about the board’s role: advocacy versus advice.

Fiebig said he objected to the proposal after raising concerns about whether it aligned with the board’s newly developed strategic plan. In his resignation letter, Fiebig claims the disagreement between himself and Perkins escalated to the point where Perkins pressured staff to change Fiebig’s vote from “dissent” to “abstain” in the meeting minutes (a claim Perkins denies). The meeting minutes reflect a dissenting vote. 

Fiebig also stated that, later in the meeting, Perkins delivered a “lengthy monologue” discouraging criticism of the police.

“The effect was that CPAB members were to fall in line and to keep their perspectives — as well as any perspectives you all might share in other venues — out of the room,” Fiebig said in his letter to council. 

The exchange prompted Fiebig to resign. 

“It was pretty heated,” he recalled in an interview with CityView. “He was defensive. I was hot. After that … I turned to [Assistant City Manager Jeffrey] Yates, who’s sitting next to me, and I said, ‘I’ll be turning in my resignation tonight or tomorrow.’ And then I left.”

Perkins acknowledged that, based on the interaction at the meeting, Fiebig felt his “first-amendment rights were being breached for some reason.” But he declined to comment on Fiebig’s specific claims in the letter or his rationale for leaving, and denied that he had directed staff to alter the meeting minutes.

“I don’t have any comment about what he said or why he chose to leave,” Perkins told CityView. 

Perkins also claimed that advocacy for the police department is prescribed by the board’s charter. 

The charter contains one explicit mention of advocacy, encouraging members to “educate and advocate with the public.” Another goal tasks the board with providing support to “celebrate agency successes.” 

CPAB charter

Fiebig and Grace’s description of the board’s advocacy on behalf of the police department aligns with comments made by board members at recent meetings. At the November 2024 meeting, Perkins encouraged members to record and collect all feedback from the public as part of an ongoing community canvassing initiative, as well as question their perceptions of the police department.

Treasure Heffney, who is spearheading the board’s community canvassing initiative, described correcting “misinformation” or negative views of the police department. 

“The more I’m willing to talk about the things that we speak about in here and just give correct information, I feel a lot more people are becoming comfortable with the idea of being connected to the police department, opposed to the negative side of it,” Heffney said at the November 2024 board meeting. “But I think we really just have to keep talking about it, about the positive things.”

Members of CPAB are required to attend the 10-week Citizens Police Academy and participate in a police ride-a-long. Only two other of the city’s 26 volunteer boards, the Historic Resources Commission and the Human Relations Commission, have training requirements in their by-laws, according to a city spokesperson. 

Fiebig argued the CPAB’s training requirements, by placing an emphasis on engagement with the police department and not the community, seemed geared toward cultivating an “us vs. them” mindset among its members. 

“It became clear that, ‘Oh, the reason that they want a ride along and participation in Citizens Police Academy is because they want us thinking like in the police mindset as we give feedback to them,’” Fiebig told CityView. 

Research suggests police training as it’s currently provided can bring about a divisive mentality between law enforcement and the communities they serve. A 2018 study published in Police Practice & Research: An International Journal found that cadets undergoing police training “increasingly disidentify with the rest of the population” by taking on an us vs. them mentality. A 2024 study published in the Police Quarterly found that this us vs. them mentality was linked to “problematic orientations about use of force and citizen interactions” among police officers. 

Grace, who resigned last January, said he didn’t believe the board was about advocating for the police department when he joined it. But over time, his feelings changed.

“Everything I read about [in the charter] when I joined was that we were supposed to be a neutral party, be like a liaison between the citizens and the police department,” Grace told CityView, “not to agree with everything the police department does.”

Perkins accused departing members of wanting to transform CPAB into an oversight and accountability board, a role he asserts is outside the charter’s scope. 

“What many who have left the board — I guess because they felt that we weren’t doing what we were supposed to do — I always say to them, but what does our charter say?” Perkins said. “And so we are not there to admonish the police department. We’re not there to enforce police standards. We are there, based on what those nine objectives are, to assess and make recommendations. And so we’re not an adversarial board when it comes to the police department.”

Another board member, retired parole officer Pablo Arroyo, said those critical of the police department had a chip on their shoulder. 

“No matter what the police department does, they want to keep that chip,” he said at the November 2024 CPAB meeting. “It doesn’t matter.”

Neither Fiebig nor Grace said that they wanted CPAB to function as an accountability board with oversight power. Instead, they argued it should not withhold criticism — or praise — of the police department when warranted. Fiebig said that he didn’t object to all advocacy work but felt the board had swung too far in that direction. 

“In our fear of creating the opposite — perhaps that opposite is a review board comprised only of enraged activists who have nothing but awful things to say about FPD — we have created something at least as unhelpful,” Fiebig said. 

Ineffectiveness and dysfunction

CPAB’s charter states its “primary function is to make recommendations to City Council and provide the citizens of Fayetteville with information.” The board should also assess and suggest improvements to police department policies and procedures on a regular basis.

Perkins, when questioned by city council members and in an interview with CityView, was unable to name a single recommendation for the police department made by the board. 

“I don’t remember off the top of my head what recommendations we’ve made,” he said at the council meeting. In an interview with CityView a few days later, Perkins claimed that the board had made a recommendation to the police department but he “failed to communicate that with the council.” When pressed, however, he still could not name a policy.

“I would have to go back [and look] because I don’t want to be misquoted and I don’t want to misstate what actually happened and which particular policy it was,” Perkins said.

According to Fiebig and Grace, when suggestions for improvement of the police department are offered by CPAB members, they are quickly put to rest.

Both raised concerns about what they perceive as Perkins’ bias toward the police department, arguing his influence as chair has stifled CPAB’s ability to effectively advise the police department. They contended his lack of neutrality suppressed dissent and encouraged conformity.

Grace says he was bullied by Perkins at meetings. Once, he says, he tried to offer feedback about the contentious youth curfew ordinance when the city council considered it in the fall of 2023. After emailing Perkins with his concerns, Perkins allegedly chastised him at a CPAB meeting, refused to let him ask Fayetteville Police Chief Kemberle Braden questions about it, and threatened to read the email aloud. Grace also claimed Perkins falsely stated that Braden had not proposed the curfew. Braden proposed the curfew, and it was written by the police department’s attorney. 

“I was told I was absolutely wrong on this in the CPAB meeting,” Grace said. “I was not even allowed to ask Chief Braden one single question about the youth curfew, or anything else for that matter.”

Grace added that Perkins threatened to read his email aloud, “as if he was going to embarrass me or something.” 

Perkins confirmed that he did not allow Grace the opportunity to question Braden and said he asked permission to read the email aloud at the meeting. He claimed it would be “unfair” to question Braden about the curfew because the council had not yet made a decision on the curfew. 

“The board gave me broad authority to cut discussions, to table discussions or to limit discussions on topics that are not of relevance to our nine core values and/or not of relevance to the current conversation,” Perkins told CityView. “What I said to Mr. Grace … is that council is still in discussion about juvenile curfew, and they have not directed the chief to begin to enforce a curfew, so I thought that it was unfair for him to ask the chief.”

At the October 2023 meeting, attended by CityView, Perkins reiterated that Braden had not proposed the curfew and repeatedly told Grace he was “out of order” when Grace tried to correct him.

Adding to these concerns about Perkins’ conduct at meetings, both Grace and Fiebig questioned Perkins’ close ties to the police department as a police chaplain. At the October 2024 meeting, he stated he has a key card to access the police department and city hall. He is also heavily involved in the police department’s Faith in Action program, in which police and faith leaders give free food and harm reduction supplies in low-income neighborhoods. 

Fiebig said learning about Perkins’ involvement with the Faith in Action program, in addition to being a police chaplain, “set off alarm bells” about a potential conflict of interest.

“That is sort of emblematic of what I wrote about, which is like, we don’t have a neutral chair,” Fiebig said, referring to his resignation letter. He argued the board needs diverse voices to provide balanced feedback, which Perkins’ other positions preclude. 

Perkins declined to comment on these neutrality claims. Grace suggested the board should be disbanded if Perkins’ leadership continues.

“Until there’s a different chairperson there that’s more neutral and will allow the board members to be able to ask questions . . . nothing’s gonna get any better,” Grace told CityView. “It’s just gonna keep getting worse and worse.” 

An uncertain future

Still, Fiebig said that, as much as Perkins’ influence has compounded CPAB’s troubles, CPAB’s problems are really rooted in its “impossible” charter. He believes the CPAB’s charter, with its nine goals, is too broad, making it difficult for the all-volunteer board to effectively address any single issue. He suggests the charter was intentionally designed to be palatable to the police department, with stipulations about it being strictly advisory and extensive requirements of attendees.

“What I’ve been able to sort of stitch together as a version of what I think is true is that maybe when that charter was created by city council, in order to just get something done, they had to make it safe enough for the police department to experience,” Fiebig said. “And so it is a document that . . . has all these safeguards in place about the kind of feedback and the lane you have to stay in and all that. And so between that charter and a chair who’s sympathetic to that vibe, it’s become an advocacy group.” 

Perkins, in a way, agreed. He and other members at the November meeting discussed the possibility of transforming CPAB into a “community safety” rather than police advisory board. Perkins highlighted the board’s new strategic plan, which has three objectives:

  • Create a space for community dialogue around policing and community safety.
  • Create a space for transparency and information concerning policing and community safety issues.
  • Create a space to build connection between policing practices and the community.

Perkins said CPAB’s founding was intertwined with the Black Lives Matter protests and the council’s desire at the time for police accountability. Various cities with police review boards in North Carolina have attempted to pass state legislation granting those boards investigative authority to review police personnel records and have subpoena power, but none have been successful. 

“They wanted an oversight agency and they didn’t get that because by state statute they can’t do that,” Perkins said. “And so this board is the compromise of that. And perhaps that’s been our struggle over the last three years as a new board is identity, getting our foot in, we’ve got these nine goals and while I think we’re still crawling, I think we’ll be able to come out much clearer in the long run.”

For the CPAB members who resigned, they say the issue wasn’t about creating conflict with the police. Their primary concern was the board’s failure, in their eyes, to effectively serve the public interest.

“This is just a disservice to all the citizens of Fayetteville,” Grace told CityView. “The citizens deserve a lot better than what’s happened with the Community Police Advisory Board.”


Contact Evey Weisblat at eweisblat@cityviewnc.com or 216-527-3608. This story was made possible by donations from readers like you to CityView News Fund, a 501(c)(3) charitable organization committed to an informed democracy in Fayetteville and Cumberland County.

Evey Weisblat is a journalist with five years of experience in local news reporting. She has previously worked at papers in central North Carolina, including The Pilot and the Chatham News + Record. Her central beat is government accountability reporting, covering the Fayetteville City Council.

One reply on “Fayetteville Community Police Advisory Board is ‘cheerleader’ for police department, ex-members claim ”

Comments are closed.