Log in Newsletter

Board of Education endorses option for electoral redistricting maps

Plan would keep all incumbents in separate districts


The Cumberland County Board of Education on Tuesday endorsed an electoral redistricting plan that would make minimal changes in district lines and keep all board incumbents in separate districts.

The board considered three options for electoral redistricting maps. In a unanimous vote, the picked Option A.

Adam Mitchell, a consultant with the Raleigh-based law firm Tharrington Smith, told the board that the electoral map change would have nothing to do with student assignments.

He then gave an abbreviated version of an earlier presentation to highlight key points.

“So, if you remember, electoral redistricting is based on the principle of one person, one vote,” Mitchell told the board.

Every 10 years following the federal census, local governments are given the flexibility of having plus or minus 5% of what’s considered the ideal population in electoral districts, he said.

“We looked at your current districts. Some of them were in balance, but not all of them,” he said.

Mitchell said that board members expressed a desire “to preserve the core of the existing districts instead of just throwing them out and starting from scratch to avoid pairing incumbents in the same district and not to take into account future growth, which is an option but definitely not required.”

A public hearing was held before the meeting began to give residents an opportunity to comment. No one spoke during the hearing.

The redistricting plans are online on the Cumberland County Board of Elections website. Go to Click here for the Board of Elections website. Maps are also available by calling 910-678-2304.

Mitchell said Option A would offer a minimalistic approach. Districts 1 and 6 would not change. It would move the Brentwood precinct from District 2 to District 3 and move the Hope Mills 3 precinct from District 6 to District 4. The plan would keep each incumbent in a separate district.

All six of the districts would be in compliance with a plus or minus 5% ideal population, he said.

Option B would also be a minimalistic approach, he said, leaving Districts 1 and 6 unchanged. It would move a small part of Fort Bragg (Manchester precinct) from District 2 to District 3. That area has about 800 residents and is near the Special Operations Command Headquarters on Fort Bragg.

Option B also would move Pearces Mills 3 — which includes Fayetteville Regional Airport — from District 6 to District 4 and a small part of Hope Mills 2B precinct, the section north of Rockfish Creek, from District 6 to District 4. It would keep each incumbent in a separate district.

Option C would leave Districts 1 and 6 intact but move a small part of Brentwood precinct from District 2 to District 3 and all of Sherwood precinct from District 6 to District 4. Incumbents would still be in separate districts.

Mitchell noted a couple of online comments about the electoral redistricting that included one from a Cumberland County Schools teacher or staff member.

The individual called Option C the least favorite “as our school district will be split apart. This will cause our representation to be significantly weakened.”

An unnamed parent or guardian expressed a preference for Option A “since it splits the fewest number of precinct results in the most evenly distributed population totals for all six districts.”

The Board of Education then voted unanimously to name Option A its preferred plan.

Mitchell said the consultants will prepare a resolution in support of Option A for the board to consider at its next meeting.

Michael Futch covers Fayetteville and education for CityView TODAY. He can be reached at mfutch@cityviewnc.com. Have a news tip? Email news@CityViewTODAY.com.

Cumberland County, Fayetteville, school board, education